Protecting Arizona Retail: Policy, AI, and the Fight Against Organized Crime (with Michelle Ahlmer of the Arizona Retailers Association)
In this episode of the Knoodle Founders Hour, host Rosaria Cain sits down with Michelle Ahlmer, Executive Director of the Arizona Retailers Association, to explore the challenges facing today’s retailers, the evolving relationship between business and government, and what it takes to keep Arizona a thriving place for entrepreneurs.
With more than 30 years at the helm of the Arizona Retailers Association, Michelle has dedicated her career to advocating for the businesses that drive Arizona’s economy. Raised in a family of retail entrepreneurs, she learned the value of customer relationships and hard work at an early age. Today, she brings that same passion to the intersection of retail, public policy, and economic growth, helping businesses navigate everything from rising costs to organized retail crime and emerging technology.
In this episode, you’ll discover:
- The Fight for Affordable Retail: How rising supply chain costs, government regulations, and economic pressures are challenging retailers to keep prices competitive while maintaining profitability.
- Combating Organized Retail Crime: The surprising sophistication of organized theft networks, their impact on consumer prices, and how Arizona’s Organized Retail Crime Alliance brings retailers and law enforcement together to fight back.
- The Future of Retail and Agentic AI: How artificial intelligence is transforming shopping, inventory management, and consumer behavior, and why retailers must adapt to an increasingly automated marketplace.
- Advocating for Arizona Businesses: How Michelle and the Arizona Retailers Association have influenced legislation, including the taxation of online sales, while navigating an increasingly complex political landscape.
- The Entrepreneurial Mindset: Why passion, thoughtful decision-making, adaptability, and a deep understanding of your customers are essential ingredients for building a successful business.
- From the Sales Floor to Leadership: How Michelle’s childhood working in her family’s clothing store shaped her career, her commitment to personal relationships, and her belief that retail offers far more career opportunities than most people realize.
Entrepreneurs, retail professionals, business owners, and anyone interested in Arizona’s economic future will gain valuable insights from Michelle’s decades of experience advocating for one of the state’s most essential industries.
Listen to the full episode of the Knoodle Founders Hour podcast to hear Michelle’s perspective on the future of retail, the power of relationships, and what it takes to help businesses succeed in an ever-changing world.
Full Transcript
Rosaria Cain 0:21
Good morning, Michelle. Good morning. So glad you’re here.
Michelle Ahlmer 0:24
Thank you. I’m glad to be here. Thanks for the opportunity.
Rosaria Cain 0:27
And 27 years as executive director.
Michelle Ahlmer 0:31
30 years.
Rosaria Cain 0:32
30 years as executive. Wow. Yeah.
Michelle Ahlmer 0:34
33 with the association. 30 as the exec.
Michelle Ahlmer 0:37
That’s incredible. Did you know you were going to stay that long when you when you chose that avenue.
Michelle Ahlmer 0:43
No, and in fact, I never envisioned this career path at all.
Rosaria Cain 0:48
Is this gonna be like your last job ever?
Michelle Ahlmer 0:51
Yeah.
Michelle Ahlmer 0:52
That is.
Michelle Ahlmer 0:52
Well, I don’t know. That’s a good question. I think it’ll be my last career. I may do more of a brainless job.
Michelle Ahlmer 1:04
Or consulting, where you have more freedom.
Michelle Ahlmer 1:06
Yes, yes. Or right now, a greeter, a door greeter, sounds pretty good.
Michelle Ahlmer 1:11
You know, I’m thinking hamburger flipping. I’ve been at my job 27 years, and there are days it’s you never stop thinking about it.
Michelle Ahlmer 1:18
Yes, yeah, you carry it around with you all the time. It’s what you look at everywhere you go. You see visions of what you work at nine to five, and that’s a gross exaggeration. It’s more like you know.
Rosaria Cain 1:33
Don’t I wish it was nine to five? I was going to say. Well, the Arizona Retailers Association, you carry 1700 storefronts with you around every day.
Michelle Ahlmer 1:44
Yes, and that’s every time I drive by one and I see store closing, it breaks my heart. And grand opening, I get another burst of hope. I take it very personal.
Rosaria Cain 1:55
I can understand. And is it true that you’re the only group that deals with retail alone?
Michelle Ahlmer 2:00
Yeah, significantly. Just retail. There are other groups that do like like the grocers have food marketing, so they have marketers, wholesalers. But we’re retail solely.
Michelle Ahlmer 2:14
That’s great. Well, and no wonder you have so many members. So, what’s the elevator speech when people ask what you do and what the Arizona Retailers Association.
Michelle Ahlmer 2:24
I have to give that a lot because people don’t really know what what that means. But so we’re a membership organization, and our sole focus is to advocate for retailers with policymakers. And basically, in a nutshell, I try to keep Arizona safe to sell stuff.
Michelle Ahlmer 2:44
That’s great. Now you sit at the intersection of business, government, and public policy, which is quite an intersection. Is there part of it you love the most?
Michelle Ahlmer 2:56
Yeah, I really believe in retail and the principles that are foundational in retail. I was raised in a retail family, and so I really like advocating for the retail process and what it can mean to a community, what it can mean to an individual, and what it means to the business to be able to flourish in an environment.
Michelle Ahlmer 3:25
and you fight for real for retail.
Michelle Ahlmer 3:28
You do, yeah.
Michelle Ahlmer 3:30
And how is that exactly with the state government?
Michelle Ahlmer 3:33
You know, we’ve been very successful. It it’s challenging because retail used to be kind of viewed as this sleepy little industry, part of the business sector that we just kind of supplied stuff, but now it has become kind of this focus of a lot of societal angst, and so we face a lot more challenges than we did 30 years ago.
Michelle Ahlmer 4:06
So tell me about this angst. What is fueling that, and what is the angst about?
Michelle Ahlmer 4:11
You know, I think that there’s a lot of passionate advocates on both sides. Like, but we’re feeling the heat from people who want to see social changes take place at business at the business level, and we’ve seen some businesses who suffered from trying to take a position on social issues, and it’s just better for them to for all businesses to stay in their lane and provide quality merchandise at a affordable price.
Michelle Ahlmer 4:43
So, are you recommending, because this is always an issue for all types of businesses, including the ad agency business, that people don’t take a position on social issues because of the potential consequences?
Michelle Ahlmer 4:55
I think as a company, it you’re trying to appeal. Especially in retail, you’re trying to gather customers from every sector. You don’t want to just be targeting one particular demographic. And and if you do, you wind up in this current environment. There is such division that you wind up alienating one or the other. So while on an individual basis, I believe that you stand up for what you believe in as an individual. But as my company, I want to be able to reach everyone, especially as a retailer. I want to be able to serve the community as a whole.
Michelle Ahlmer 5:37
What are some of the big issues that are plaguing retailers right now?
Michelle Ahlmer 5:41
Affordability is number one. You hear it every day from every sector. Everything costs more. Yeah, and they are trying to make products available in an affordable manner, and still make a profit so that they can employ people and keep their doors open and continue to provide a service and and products. So, trying to walk that line is really challenging when you have pressures from government and from just the supply chain. Everything that comes into providing a product comes into play when when you talk about affordability and the cost of transportation alone, and then the manufacturing.
Michelle Ahlmer 6:24
And gas goes up. Everything else goes up.
Michelle Ahlmer 6:26
Exactly.
Rosaria Cain 6:27
Any other issues that come to mind that have been?
Michelle Ahlmer 6:29
Oh yeah, AI is everywhere, and the discussion on AI is really huge in terms of how it touches. We’ve been using AI in retail for a long time, like we use it for logistics. We use it for product or inventory control.It’s been a tool that we didn’t even refer to as AI previously. Now it has advanced so much that we’re looking right now. I just got back from a national conference where we had a pretty significant discussion on something called Agentic AI, which is taking it from having AI write a report for you to telling, if your AI friend is Harold, you say, Harold, please prepare a menu for an Italian dinner, fill my shopping cart with everything I need, and have it delivered by 5 o’clock tonight. And it does all of it for you. And so, moving to that kind of an advanced level is a challenge for retailers from an administrative standpoint. How do they process that? How do they work within that AI system? And also, how do they face forward with the consumer on making that available? And how do we manage it so that it is protecting people’s privacy and all of those intricacies that AI presents?
Michelle Ahlmer 7:58
No, that is interesting because they say people don’t go to websites anymore.
Michelle Ahlmer 8:03
Yeah.
Rosaria Cain 8:03
They go to they go to their favorite AI channel, ChatGPT, being probably the most used, and they just ask for what they want. Then they just go buy it. So the website is sometimes not as much of a focal point as it was, or not as attributable as it was before.
Michelle Ahlmer 8:26
There’s lots of changes. It’s a very dynamic world that we live in, and retail is so key to all of that. We all have to eat. We all have to buy particular products. We all have to buy them, and so being able to adjust to that dynamic nature is challenging.
Michelle Ahlmer 8:47
And that’s just one of the changes since you started. Was it 1993?
Michelle Ahlmer 8:51
Yeah.
Rosaria Cain 8:52
What else have you seen change that is really creative?
Michelle Ahlmer 8:56
Well, we had one of our biggest battles, and thankfully we were successful for not just retail, but for the state of Arizona, is getting taxation on online sales.
Michelle Ahlmer 9:11
Was it was playing field?
Michelle Ahlmer 9:13
Yeah, evening the playing field, and also it happened. So we got it passed in 2019, and March of 2020, look what happened. Without online sales tax, the state of Arizona would have been in a really bad position fiscally.
Michelle Ahlmer 9:32
And the retailers, especially.
Michelle Ahlmer 9:34
You look at all the sales tax revenue that would have been lost because the sales would have still taken place, and everybody ramped up their their e-commerce presence, but without the sales tax being applied to those purchases, the state budget would have taken a significant hit.
Michelle Ahlmer 9:53
And I bet you got a thank you note from the state government.
Michelle Ahlmer 9:57
I’m waiting. I think they missed my address.
Michelle Ahlmer 10:00
Well, they miss everybody’s address. So, how has your relationship changed with the legislature since you started? So, you’ve probably seen some trends. You’ve probably seen it evolve.
Michelle Ahlmer 10:09
Yes.
Rosaria Cain 10:10
How have you seen it change in the last I don’t know 30 years? Gosh, you’ve been around a lot. We both have.
Michelle Ahlmer 10:15
Yes, I have. It has evolved a lot. Like I said earlier, we used to be kind of a sleepy business group, not sleepy, but we weren’t fighting hard, having really difficult battles, and that has changed. When one of the first wins that occurred when I started was, and I worked with my dad for three years, so he had this position before me. So nepotism worked for me. But I remember celebrating that.
Michelle Ahlmer 10:48
That and you probably learned a lot.
Michelle Ahlmer 10:49
Oh yeah.
Michelle Ahlmer 10:50
It probably wasn’t easy on you.
Michelle Ahlmer 10:51
No, we had major clashes, and then we’d retreat. It was great learning on a business and a personal basis, but he had his one of the big wins after I first started was allowing retailers to put shelf tags on the shelf instead of having to individually put a sticker on every item. Doesn’t that seem like we’ve had shelf tags for ever?
Michelle Ahlmer 11:19
I don’t remember before we had shelf tags.
Michelle Ahlmer 11:21
Yeah, when you’d have the little sticker. You still see it in some stores, like the dollar store. Dollar Tree. They still apply stickers occasionally, and if you thrift, you see stickers on there. But that was we had to change the law to allow for shelf tags to be placed.
Michelle Ahlmer 11:41
Don’t our legislators have enough to do?
Michelle Ahlmer 11:42
Well, there was a lot of consumer groups that were very concerned about that, and the scanning, scanning was terrifying for the consumer groups when it first came out. They thought that it was never going to be accurate, and it’s actually far more accurate.
Michelle Ahlmer 11:59
I was going to say missing a digit could really cost a lot of money.
Michelle Ahlmer 12:03
Exactly and we have all kinds of studies that show it’s so much more accurate.
Michelle Ahlmer 12:08
Now we scan everything.
Michelle Ahlmer 12:09
Yeah. So it’s been that was one of our first challenges. But at that time, it everything was pretty pro business in Arizona. The Senate was under Democratic leadership, but even at that time, it was more…
Michelle Ahlmer 12:26
Who was governor then?
Michelle Ahlmer 12:27
Symington when I started.
Rosaria Cain 12:30
Okay, all right. That was turbulent.
Michelle Ahlmer 12:31
Yeah, that was. So, and actually, no, I’m wrong. It was Jane Hall.
Michelle Ahlmer 12:39
Oh, okay, all right. That was right. Right after. Was that right after?
Michelle Ahlmer 12:44
I’m getting it all wrong.
Michelle Ahlmer 12:45
Wait. I either.
Michelle Ahlmer 12:49
Okay, I’m losing my memory.
Michelle Ahlmer 12:51
Me too.
Michelle Ahlmer 12:51
Anyway, been through it all.
Michelle Ahlmer 12:52
Yeah.
Michelle Ahlmer 12:53
So we had we have a lot of changes where conservative Republicans are becoming very populist, and progressive Democrats are also very populist.
Rosaria Cain 13:11
So they’re going to the left.
Michelle Ahlmer 13:12
Well, they’re going so far right. Yeah, it’s kind of turning into this circular argument. So you’ve got conservative here and progressive here, and then they come all the way around to where they’re touching on occasion.
Michelle Ahlmer 13:26
So, is it that they’re both going to the extremes of their own party?
Michelle Ahlmer 13:29
Yeah.
Rosaria Cain 13:29
Is that okay?
Michelle Ahlmer 13:31
Yeah.
Rosaria Cain 13:31
So they’re getting socialist.
Michelle Ahlmer 13:33
I don’t think so. It is more populist. So reacting to whatever they’re hearing from their constituents, and that’s a good representative government. But it also takes it’s like getting a piece of the story. You need to have the full story to make good decisions, and sometimes we’re not getting all that.
Michelle Ahlmer 13:55
No, I can tell you that’s absolutely true. What’s the biggest misconception people have about retail in general? You probably face this a lot. It’s probably hard for you to give me one, but give me a few.
Michelle Ahlmer 14:07
I’ll give you a few. That it’s a dead end job, and we like to think of it as a entry level job that can you can upskill into a million different areas. You can go from. It’s always fascinating to me when I hear about retail CEOs that started as a salesperson. And all the changes that they go through. That’s kind of a direct chain that you can see. You go from sales clerk to assistant manager, manager, district manager, and on up the chain. But if you think about it, if somebody starts in retail and they express an interest in in logistics, there’s a pathway for them. If they want to be involved in in computer graphics, there’s a pathway. If they. Want to be involved in AI? There’s a pathway. There’s so many things are involved in a successful retail business that there is so many job opportunities that I like to always talk about how we can upskill and really provide great training, and it’s the best training in the world to have as a first job because you have to learn how to get along with your coworkers and with the public, and both of those can be challenging.
Rosaria Cain 15:29
Can also teach you to sell.
Michelle Ahlmer 15:30
Yes, which can be really a lucrative career.
Rosaria Cain 15:33
Yes, in anything you do.
Michelle Ahlmer 15:35
Exactly.
Michelle Ahlmer 15:35
And marketing.
Michelle Ahlmer 15:36
My mom was one of the best retail salespeople I’ve ever witnessed. She knew her customers, so we had our own our own retail stores.
Michelle Ahlmer 15:48
Tell me about that? What it was like?
Michelle Ahlmer 15:50
It was in Helena, Montana, and we sold high end fashion for that little town at that time. It’s not like we had the designers that you see now, but at that time, it was really the nicest store in town, and so we, my mom, would connect with her customers in in a friend basis. She knew them, she knew what where they were going and what they were doing, and and she would make notes after they had come in the store, and then she would contact them and say, “I just got a new shipment in of dresses, and there’s one that’s going to be a beautiful color on you. You should just come in and try it.” And that made them feel special, made my mom enjoy her job more, and it just showed me how much value there is on that one to one connection, and making sure that you know the people you’re trying to work with.
Michelle Ahlmer 16:46
And that thread is carried has carried with you.
Michelle Ahlmer 16:48
Yeah.
Rosaria Cain 16:49
No, that’s great.
Michelle Ahlmer 16:50
Really, that’s what makes my job pleasurable is knowing my members, and knowing the legislators and the policymakers that I work with.
Michelle Ahlmer 17:00
Well, what’s on the mind of retailers right now?
Michelle Ahlmer 17:03
Like I mentioned, that agentic AI is key for everybody. They’re trying to figure out that balance and how to make it work and how to be. I think that the opportunities for growth in that are significant, but finding the balance is going to be key.
Michelle Ahlmer 17:23
What about organized retail theft? I understand you have quite a presence on that category. You’re spokesman, you speak on that quite often. Tell us about the what is it? What’s the extent of it? And what are we doing about it?
Michelle Ahlmer 17:41
Okay, well, we’re lucky in Arizona. We’ve got some good good statutes that we can have our law enforcement and prosecutors look to to be able to use to stop or at least try to stem the tide of it. But organized retail theft is different than shoplifting. Shoplifting is for your own personal use, so we’re not going after people who are trying to feed their families. Organized retail theft is theft with the intent to resell. So this is a way that people are making a living. What we see is that people will come into a store. We refer to them as boosters. They’re the ones that are actually taking the product, but they’re taking it most of the time. Sometimes they’re their own booster and fence, but the booster generally has a shopping list.
Michelle Ahlmer 18:31
What’s a booster? Let me just stop right there.
Michelle Ahlmer 18:34
Okay, they’re the ones that come into the store and steal whatever they’ve been sent to steal.
Michelle Ahlmer 18:40
So they find a lot of it?
Michelle Ahlmer 18:41
Oh yeah, and it depends. Like if they’re after a generator, they’re not going to take more than one of those. But if they’re taking cosmetics or skincare, they try to take as much as possible, and they’ll clear out an entire shelf.
Michelle Ahlmer 18:58
Do they? But isn’t that pretty obvious?
Michelle Ahlmer 19:01
Yeah, and it’s not as though we don’t know. Cameras are everywhere in retail.
Rosaria Cain 19:06
Right.
Michelle Ahlmer 19:07
So if you’re in a retail store, don’t mistake that you aren’t on camera. You are, but we don’t want to engage. We don’t want our employees, and we certainly don’t want our customers to engage with them because it’s getting to be more aggressive in a more violent crime, but so the booster. I’ll go back to what they are. They’re the ones that come in and steal, and they’re generally doing it at the behest of a fence who is kind of their boss, and they are given direction on what they should go and steal.
Michelle Ahlmer 19:41
So it’s actually…
Michelle Ahlmer 19:43
It is an organized effort.
Michelle Ahlmer 19:45
It’s a business.
Michelle Ahlmer 19:45
It’s a business.
Michelle Ahlmer 19:46
It’s a illegal business, but it’s a business.
Michelle Ahlmer 19:48
Absolutely, it is big business.
Michelle Ahlmer 19:50
With structure.
Michelle Ahlmer 19:50
Very much because they know what will sell.
Michelle Ahlmer 19:54
It’s like organized crime.
Michelle Ahlmer 19:55
Yeah, it is.
Michelle Ahlmer 19:56
It is organized crime.
Michelle Ahlmer 19:57
It is, and so there is a fence, and that’s who we try. Because the the people who come in and steal, the boosters, they can find a million of those. They’re generally people who are a lot of them are drug addicts or homeless, so they’re kind of disadvantaged in that regard. So they’re looking for a way to make a dime, and that doesn’t excuse illegal behavior. But the fence, the head of the spear, is who we’re really after. So what we have created is something called the Organized Retail Crime Alliance, which brings together retailers from all any anyone that has someone who investigates this is welcome to join in the retail community, and then there’s law enforcement, regular local police officers, as well as prosecutors, homeland security, Secret Service, Postal Service.
Michelle Ahlmer 20:56
So it’s all the way up on on on the other side as well.
Michelle Ahlmer 20:57
Yeah, and they are on a controlled website where they can put up like a description of the event and still photograph or video if they have it of suspects. That way, if someone’s stealing from one retailer, they can post that and the other retailers can look at it and go, “Oh, we know that guy too.”
Michelle Ahlmer 21:19
Now, are these the boosters out there?
Michelle Ahlmer 21:22
Once in a while we get the fence.
Michelle Ahlmer 21:25
So do we ever arrest the boosters?
Michelle Ahlmer 21:27
Yeah, they will. But if they can stop them on the property? They want to do that. If they can’t, then what we do is collect the video and be able to share that, and even after they’re arrested, share it because we want to build a case against them.
Rosaria Cain 21:46
Makes sense.
Michelle Ahlmer 21:47
And so we’ll have somebody like I was in Washington D.C. last week, and they had a news report on a woman who was involved in a car theft. She was trying to escape police because she had 20 warrants out, all of them organized retail theft warrants for her, and she had stolen over like I can’t remember the figure, but it was like in the you know like $20,000 worth of cosmetics in one incident, and so she was trying to escape police. She hijacked a car, got in a car accident, and the passenger died. So she’s just ruined her life. Other people’s lives, obviously. But that type of behavior is common, where we see repeat offenders over and over and over again who are doing this. We have gangs of people who’ve come through the state that are have come here from other countries, and they know, like the organizer of them, or the boss, or the fence is watching where prosecutions are taking place, and they’ll move them out of that state.
Michelle Ahlmer 22:59
We had like chess pieces.
Michelle Ahlmer 23:00
Yeah. It is very organized, and it cost Arizona in 2022 is the last study that we have that we can refer to 1.5 billion in Arizona, and what that does to you and I is increases prices and impacts affordability. But it also we don’t want that kind of element in our neighborhoods, and it’s in every neighborhood. This doesn’t just happen in certain areas of town. It’s in every neighborhood, in every size retailer, from the smallest independent to the largest retailers are all subject to this. And because of the anonymity that goes with online sales, that’s where they’re fencing their goods. So if you’re online and you see a deal that’s too good to be true, it might be stolen merchandise.
Rosaria Cain 23:50
And there’s no way to vet that.
Michelle Ahlmer 23:52
Not really, other than to be aware that if it’s for sale in mass quantity, if you can buy 10 of something and it’s way under retail market price. There’s something wrong.
Michelle Ahlmer 24:04
Wow, that’s something to think about.
Michelle Ahlmer 24:06
Yeah, yeah.
Rosaria Cain 24:07
So you started out working for your dad. Tell me how it progressed into the position you are now.
Michelle Ahlmer 24:16
Oh, how far back do you want me to go?
Rosaria Cain 24:18
Well, so I’m sure when you were working for your mom at the best clothing store in town in Helena, I imagine was that while you were in college?
Michelle Ahlmer 24:29
High school.
Rosaria Cain 24:30
High school. Okay, so junior high.
Michelle Ahlmer 24:32
I started at age of 12. So yeah.
Michelle Ahlmer 24:36
Not against the law.
Michelle Ahlmer 24:37
Not if it’s your mom.
Michelle Ahlmer 24:40
My parents had a shop as well.
Michelle Ahlmer 24:42
So you know what I’m talking about. They just gave me lots of opportunities, and I think it was to keep me out of trouble a lot of the time. But I would go after school and wash hangers and sweep floors. My mom never wanted hanger grease, when you hold your hanger and you get those little black marks. Not in my mom’s store, so I had to walk wax down the rods with wax paper to keep that from happening, and then on up the line, steaming the clothes, pricing the clothes into selling. And at age 15 or 16, my dad asked me to start making collection calls because
Rosaria Cain 25:21
Oh fun. That is so much fun.
Michelle Ahlmer 25:23
They carried their own credit so they would oh they’d have house credit so I would call and say hi this is you know calling from Sheila’s fine apparel and trying to see if what we can do to help you pay your account.
Michelle Ahlmer 25:37
That’s a great learning experience.
Michelle Ahlmer 25:40
Intimidating. I think he knew that they were less likely to hang up on this little high schooler than they
Rosaria Cain 25:46
Feel bad, maybe more likely to feel bad.
Michelle Ahlmer 25:49
Exactly. So, and then I went to school. I got a paralegal certificate and worked for a lot of business law firms, and then came to work for my dad at the retail association, and he worked actually for the Montana Retail Association, and then found out that the Arizona executive was retiring, and so he applied for the job, and they moved down here full time, and I moved here from another state and worked as in a law firm for about a year and then went to work for the association.
Michelle Ahlmer 26:28
That’s great background. Do you ever regret leaving Montana?
Michelle Ahlmer 26:32
No.
Michelle Ahlmer 26:33
Because it’s so pretty. Everyone wants to move there.
Michelle Ahlmer 26:37
Well, until you have to plug your car in to make sure that it’ll turn on and scrape ice. I don’t miss the cold weather I have about a four degree temperature comfort zone so I’m glad to be here.
Michelle Ahlmer 26:51
But it’s so hot. Do you ever worry about worry that?
Michelle Ahlmer 26:53
I love the heat.
Michelle Ahlmer 26:55
Well, you’re in the right place.
Michelle Ahlmer 26:56
Yes.
Rosaria Cain 26:56
It’s a good week though to talk about this. It’s a good week to talk about it.
Michelle Ahlmer 27:00
Exactly.
Rosaria Cain 27:01
So you’ve spent your career around entrepreneurs, and I should say your childhood around entrepreneurs.
Michelle Ahlmer 27:07
Yeah.
Rosaria Cain 27:08
What separates people that are successful versus the people that don’t always make?
Michelle Ahlmer 27:15
I think passion is certainly at the top of the list, but also a combination of being a deliberate decision maker and being fleet of foot. If you can combine all of those characteristics, it’s a good recipe for success, because especially in retail, things change so quickly. The changes that small retail had to go through during the pandemic was remarkable, and those that survived, what a miracle! To be able to be that light on your feet and not make bad decisions. So that deliberate decision making, being thoughtful but not afraid to take chances and being light on your feet. I think really, I saw my mom and dad do that a lot. It always, I’m less of a risk taker than my parents were, and it still kind of amazes me the things that they were willing to jump into.
Michelle Ahlmer 28:28
No, that makes sense. And I imagine marketing has changed a lot for retailers too. They’ve had to get up to speed on so many things. AI being one of them on the marketing sense, but also digital in general, with all the different things.
Michelle Ahlmer 28:42
Yeah, and social media and digital creation, all of that is really a challenge, and it takes on a whole new dynamic, which is another opportunity for employment within the retail sector. Is all of that, that it’s huge, and it’s interesting how you see things go through changes. I was just watching some post about the the changes in fashion from the 1800s.
Michelle Ahlmer 29:10
Well and you’re probably knee deep in that because of what you did as a junior high student.
Michelle Ahlmer 29:15
Well, I’ve always liked it. That’s for sure. But to see the changes, how it went from very structured to very loose and flowy, and very structured and very loose and flowy. So, I think the demographics that we live in go through these cycles of whether it’s politics or fashion, and I’ve always found it interesting how they try to link colors with what’s happening happening in politics or fashion.
Michelle Ahlmer 29:47
What’s the end color now?
Michelle Ahlmer 29:48
Oh, I don’t even know.
Rosaria Cain 29:49
Is it purple? for Arizona?
Michelle Ahlmer 29:52
I think that that purple and lavender having a day, but so is the emerald green, like the cherry urine. That’s having a day and chocolate brown this fall.
Rosaria Cain 30:03
Chocolate brown and supposed to black.
Michelle Ahlmer 30:05
Yes, supposed to be very big this year. So I don’t know what that means for politics.
Michelle Ahlmer 30:12
It means an Italian Merida. I think it’s a pretty good shade. Okay. Well, is it easier or more difficult to start a business now since 1993 when you started?
Michelle Ahlmer 30:29
Oh, different. I think the opportunities for different, because we refer to different formats as channels, so the brick and mortar channel versus the e-commerce channel is there’s a lot more variety, a lot more that you could engage in. So that makes it easier currently, but being found, I think, is a bigger challenge. As the population grows. There’s more stores, more independent retailers. I mean, our country and certainly our state. That’s the background or the backbone of our economy is small business, and so having them be found is a challenge. And so they have to be creative about that.
Michelle Ahlmer 31:22
And that’s such an AI issue as well.
Michelle Ahlmer 31:24
Yeah.
Rosaria Cain 31:25
Being found.
Michelle Ahlmer 31:26
Yeah, it is.
Rosaria Cain 31:26
So, oh, that makes perfect sense. Is Arizona still a good place to start a business?
Michelle Ahlmer 31:31
It is. We’ve been very lucky with a lot of the laws that we have on the books. That and a lot of the regulation is lower in Arizona than it is in some other states, and that we had a governor Ducey was really good about reducing regulation. We’re still benefiting from that, and just kind of the sentiment here, we’re kind of firebrands in Arizona, and so that fits with the entrepreneurial spirit that’s here.
Michelle Ahlmer 32:04
When people aren’t successful? What do you see? What are the things that people don’t get right?
Michelle Ahlmer 32:14
I think not knowing their customer and that’s hard because we are so diverse now that trying to identify who you want to appeal to is a challenge, because you want to be loved by everybody, and but you can’t be everything to everybody, and so you’ve got to find where your passion is, what you want to engage in, and how to reach that particular populace. So I think that’s probably the most challenging thing when you lose sight of who your customer is.
Michelle Ahlmer 32:52
So marketing is kind of is one of those things not everybody has when they go into into business. They may have a product or service to sell, or a product in this case because it’s retail, but they don’t know what to do with it once they get in.
Michelle Ahlmer 33:07
Yeah, and I think it’s a combination of that and the actual merchandise itself, because if you’re going to be in a certain, if you’re trying to attract a certain demographic, you might or might not buy structured clothing, you know.
Michelle Ahlmer 33:26
Look how the pandemic changed clothing completely.
Michelle Ahlmer 33:28
Yeah, it did. Outside of clothing, just because that’s kind of what I was raised in. But, whether it’s the newest, hottest thing in technology. Knowing how, if your if your demographic is, people over 50, you choose different technology
Rosaria Cain 33:52
And different merchandise.
Michelle Ahlmer 33:53
Yes, exactly. So just knowing who you want to appeal to.
Michelle Ahlmer 33:58
Is part of what the association does is educate and create educational resources for them? like in terms of marketing or how to retail, or is that left to other groups?
Michelle Ahlmer 34:14
That’s left to other groups. Our sole focus is advocating with policymakers.
Michelle Ahlmer 34:19
And is that enough for you?
Michelle Ahlmer 34:21
Oh boy, yeah, my plate’s full.
Michelle Ahlmer 34:25
I imagine. So, do you have? I was going to ask about your personal side, what you do, but I mean, you probably don’t have a personal side.
Michelle Ahlmer 34:33
I’m lucky. I’ve been blessed with my employer that, I still have some free time.
Michelle Ahlmer 34:42
That’s good. Well, what keeps you grounded? What kind of things do you do that really that keep you in that space where you have that space?
Michelle Ahlmer 34:51
It sounds trite, and I don’t think it should be trite, but faith, family, friends. Those three things are are fundamental for me. I’m blessed with all three. I have a daughter and a son-in-law and four beautiful grandchildren, and that you know a lot of the time that I would like to spend in my free time they’re just far enough away from me that I don’t get to see them as often as I’d like. They live in north of here about three hours.
Michelle Ahlmer 35:29
Flagstaff or?
Michelle Ahlmer 35:30
No, the other direction, a little town called Baghdad between Wickenburg and Kingman.
Michelle Ahlmer 35:36
Okay, all right, yeah, kind of near Lake Havasu.
Michelle Ahlmer 35:40
No, more on the way to Vegas.
Michelle Ahlmer 35:41
Oh, okay, all right. The other side.
Michelle Ahlmer 35:44
So, and then I have an incredible network of friends, all the way from high school, college, and my current group of friends in my church and I have a lot of lobbyist friends, and I consider some legislators my friends. So I’m really blessed with a really good network, and I’m a member of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, and that faith grounds me every day.
Michelle Ahlmer 36:10
So even when you’re having a moment with the legislature, you know where to put it.
Michelle Ahlmer 36:17
Oh yeah, I have to. I have to start my day with that grounding effect, or I can lose it real quick.
Michelle Ahlmer 36:25
Well, when you look at what you’ve done, and you have had a really great legacy. I mean, not that you’re done. I should say you’re building a great legacy. You’re not done. How much more time do you want to put into this job?
Michelle Ahlmer 36:40
I don’t know. I want to be able to have enough time when I’m healthy and young enough to enjoy my grandkids before they don’t want anything to do with me. They still really like me.
Michelle Ahlmer 36:58
How old are they?
Michelle Ahlmer 36:59
Turning 13 this next week is the oldest 13, 11, 8 and the youngest will be 2, the end of the month of October.
Michelle Ahlmer 37:09
Oh, that’s a nice spread.
Michelle Ahlmer 37:10
Yeah. So they’re wonderful. The youngest is still not sure about me. He really loves his mom, but we’re gonna work on that.
Michelle Ahlmer 37:19
Sounds like sweets could be involved.
Michelle Ahlmer 37:22
Yeah, and playtime.
Michelle Ahlmer 37:25
Yeah. Well, what do you want to be known for?
Michelle Ahlmer 37:33
Oh well, with my family and my friends that I love them, and with my business relationships, that I’m dedicated.
Michelle Ahlmer 37:47
I think that’s all very cool. Now, one last question: Tell me one thing about you that would surprise people, and we’ll end with that because it’ll be a doozy, I’m sure.
Michelle Ahlmer 37:58
Yeah. So I’m glad that you warned me about that because it did take me some time to think about what would surprise, and I think that people may be surprised that if there’s good music, it has to be good music. There will be lip syncing and dancing, no matter where the grocery store, the department stores, I initially started to embarrass my daughter, but she wasn’t embarrassed, so I just kept it up.
Michelle Ahlmer 38:29
I think that’s awesome. All right, what constitutes good music?
Michelle Ahlmer 38:32
Oh, Earthwind and Fire September. I love Earthwind. That’s my favorite. I love that song.
Michelle Ahlmer 38:37
Yeah, you gotta you gotta move when that comes on.
Michelle Ahlmer 38:44
That’s great. Well, we’ll leave it from there, Miss Earth, Wind, and Fire.
Michelle Ahlmer 38:48
Thank you.
Michelle Ahlmer 38:49
And I hope you have a great day.
Michelle Ahlmer 38:50
Thank you. Thanks for letting me be here. Appreciate it.